The argument
On Instagram, insurance reels that take time to explain get the comments
By Roberto Cerda, Founder, Digital Vibes Design ·
In 109 Instagram reels from US life insurance agents, the 12 reels over 60 seconds earned a median comment rate of 0.51%, against 0.15% for the sample as a whole.
No other length bucket came close. The usual advice is to keep it short, but for a product people have questions about, the longer explanation is what gives them something to respond to. And 67% of the reels we measured end without asking the viewer to do anything, so the explanation is often doing all the work.
The second pattern is the account itself. The three strongest accounts in the sample (@insurance__cowboy at 0.42%, @t_rod19 at 0.41%, @dmndlegacygroup at 0.31%) sit well above the bottom four, which ranged from 0.00% to 0.11%. Same products, same platform, same year. What differs is the account, not the format.
What did not help was the comment-keyword prompt. The 14 reels that said "comment ACCESS" or similar reached 0.18%, against 0.22% for the 73 that asked for nothing. A keyword sorts the comments you get. In this edition it did not earn more of them.
The case against
The honest counter-argument: these are small numbers. A median of 0.15% means most agents get one comment per 645 views, and 29% of reels got none. And a comment is not a lead. Of the 24 comments we read on the top reels, none came from a consumer asking about coverage. They came from other agents and friends.
That is why the explanation matters more than the prompt. A reel that answers a real question gives a stranger a reason to ask the next one, and those are the comments worth a fast reply.
Does it hold on TikTok?
The length pattern does not carry over to TikTok. There, the 41 videos over 60 seconds reached 0.11%, below videos of 15 to 60 seconds, and the 15 videos with a comment-keyword prompt reached 0.04% against 0.19% for the 93 that asked for nothing. But TikTok comments were closer to leads: of the 37 we read, 3 came from people asking what the product was or where the agent was based, plus 5 from licensed agents answering a recruiting video.
The index updates quarterly. Subscribers see it first.